WMJ Vol 121 Issue 1: Does Unconscious Bias Affect How Pediatricians Manage Their Patients?

ABSTRACT

Background: Both implicit bias—referred to as unconscious bias—and explicit bias affect how clinicians manage patients. The Implicit Association Test (IAT) has incremental predictive validity relative to self-reports of unconscious bias. Few studies have uniquely specified the impact of unconscious bias in pediatric practices.

Objective: We aimed to assess the influence of unconscious bias on decision-making in the faculty in a pediatric academic center using the IAT, in addition to and separately applying clinical vignettes with racial and socioeconomic class associations in both tools as it relates to clinicians’ race, gender, years in practice, education achieved by the clinician’s parents, and language spoken.

Methods: We conducted a prospective quality control evaluation of faculty in an academic center’s pediatrics department. An anonymous online tool was used to gather IAT responses, clinical vignette responses, demographics, and explicit bias questions.

Results: Of 295 faculty members (73% females), 230 completed the questionnaire, at least in part. Faculty reported on the explicit bias questions, neutral feelings when comparing the demands of educated vs noneducated patients, African American vs European American patients, and patients in the upper vs lower socioeconomic class. Of the approximately two-thirds who answered the IAT, faculty showed preference for European American and upper socioeconomic class. However, the clinical vignettes revealed no differences in how faculty responded to patients based on race or socioeconomic status when stratified by factors listed above, except physicians who favor upper socioeconomic class over lower socioeconomic class were more likely to give a detailed explanation of options if the patient’s parent was upper socioeconomic class (P = 0.022).

Conclusions: Pediatricians exhibit racial and socioeconomic unconscious bias that minimally affects decision-making, at least based on vignette responses.

Target Audience

The target audience for this journal-based activity is healthcare providers caring for the people and communities of Wisconsin and beyond.

Learning Objectives

As a result of this journal-based activity, learners, as members of the healthcare team, will be able to:

  1. Discuss the published data about the impact of healthcare professionals’ uncon­scious biases on their practice of medicine.
  2. Summarize the results of a study that explored, using the Implicit Association Test and clinical vignette questions, unconscious bias and its influence on patient care decisions in an pediatric academic center.
  3. Reflect on unconscious bias in the learner’s clinical practice.
Course summary
Available credit: 
  • 1.00 AAPA Category 1 CME
  • 1.00 AMA PRA Category 1 Credit
  • 1.00 ANCC Contact Hours
  • 1.00 University of Wisconsin–Madison Continuing Education Hours
    • 1.00 Approved for AMA PRA Category 1 Credit™
Registration opens: 
09/15/2022
Course expires: 
09/14/2023
Cost:
$0.00
Rating: 
0

FACULTY DISCLOSURE

It is the policy of the University of Wisconsin–Madison Interprofessional Continuing Education Partnership (ICEP) to identify, mitigate and disclose all relevant financial relationships with ineligible companies* held by the  speakers/presenters, authors, planners, and other persons who may influence content of this accredited continuing education (CE).  In addition, speakers, presenters and authors must disclose any planned discussion of unlabeled/unapproved uses of drugs or devices during their presentation.

For this accredited continuing education activity all relevant financial relationships have been mitigated and detailed disclosures are listed below.

Name of IndividualIndividual's Role in Activity

Financial Relationship Disclosure

Discussion of
Unlabeled/Unapproved
Uses of Drugs/Devices
in Presentation?

Marianna Shershneva, MD, PhDAccreditation SpecialistNo relevant relationships with ineligible companies to discloseNo
Gisela Chelimsky, MDAuthorNo relevant relationships with ineligible companies to discloseNo
Pippa Simpson, PhDAuthorNo relevant relationships with ineligible companies to discloseNo
Mingen Feng, PhDAuthorNo relevant relationships with ineligible companies to discloseNo
Earnestine Willis, MDAuthorNo relevant relationships with ineligible companies to discloseNo
Madhulika (Mala) Mathur, MD, MPHReviewerNo relevant relationships with ineligible companies to discloseNo
Greer Jordan, MBA, PhD, BSEEReviewerNo relevant relationships with ineligible companies to discloseNo
Paula Tran Inzeo, MPHReviewerNo relevant relationships with ineligible companies to discloseNo
Robert Treat, PhDEditorNo relevant relationships with ineligible companies to discloseNo
David Dwyer, PhD, RN, NE-BCReviewerNo relevant relationships with ineligible companies to discloseNo
Laura Ozkan, PAReviewerNo relevant relationships with ineligible companies to discloseNo

*Ineligible companies are those whose primary business is producing, marketing, selling, re-selling, or distributing healthcare products used by or on, patients.

The ACCME does not consider providers of clinical services directly to patients to be ineligible companies.

The table below reflects unmitigated data. Please see the table above for final mitigated disclosure information.

Discloser List CME Internal Report

Accreditation

Accreditation Statement

Jointly Accredited Provider LogoIn support of improving patient care, this activity has been planned and implemented by the University of Wisconsin–Madison ICEP and the Wisconsin Medical Journal.  The University of Wisconsin–Madison ICEP is jointly accredited by the Accreditation Council for Continuing Medical Education (ACCME), the Accreditation Council for Pharmacy Education (ACPE), and the American Nurses Credentialing Center (ANCC), to provide continuing education for the healthcare team.


Credit Designation Statements

American Medical Association (AMA)

The University of Wisconsin–Madison ICEP designates this journal-based CE activity for a maximum of 1.0 AMA PRA Category 1 Credit™.  Physicians should claim only the credit commensurate with the extent of their participation in the activity.

American Nurses Credentialing Center (ANCC)

The University of Wisconsin–Madison ICEP designates this journal-based CE activity for a maximum of 1.0 ANCC contact hour.  

AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PHYSICIAN ASSISTANTS (AAPA)

The University of Wisconsin–Madison ICEP has been authorized by the American Academy of PAs  (AAPA) to award AAPA Category 1 CME credit for activities planned in accordance with AAPA CME Criteria. This activity is designated for 1.0 AAPA Category 1 CME credits. Approval is valid until 6/2/2023. PAs should only claim credit commensurate with the extent of their participation.

Continuing Education Units

The University of Wisconsin–Madison ICEP, as a member of the University Professional & Continuing Education Association (UPCEA), authorizes this program for 0.1 continuing education units (CEUs) or 1 hour.

Available Credit

  • 1.00 AAPA Category 1 CME
  • 1.00 AMA PRA Category 1 Credit
  • 1.00 ANCC Contact Hours
  • 1.00 University of Wisconsin–Madison Continuing Education Hours
    • 1.00 Approved for AMA PRA Category 1 Credit™

Price

Cost:
$0.00
Please login or register to take this course.

Required Hardware/software

Free, current version of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Edge. Some older browsers and Microsoft Internet Explorer could produce error messages or not display the content correctly. 

Free, current version of Adobe Acrobat Reader or other .pdf reader.